In the Fall 1997 issue of Smoke Magazine, the Caonabo Gran Jefe Torpedo was formally reviewed and received unanimous praise from the editorial panel — a distinction that now stands as documented proof of its early excellence. The cigar was described as “very pretty, smooth… almost flawless in appearance,” with perfect construction, an evenly filled body, and a flawless cap. Even before lighting, it was regarded as a top-of-the-line cigar. Once lit, the review praised its outstanding draw, remarkably consistent burn, and composed performance from head to foot. The flavor profile was noted as medium- to full-bodied, with peppery overtones balanced by subtle sweetness and impressive complexity. The aroma was described as sweet, soft, mellow, and pervasive — filling the room beautifully.